All Purpose Pizza Shop
Stepping into AP Pizza Shop on Bethesda Avenue, you immediately sense it’s not “just another pizza joint.” While many local spots offer a classic slice and a salad, this place reimagines the formula with creativity and polish. From the moment you walk in you’re greeted by a deck-oven hearth, crisp design touches, and a menu that blends familiar comfort with surprising finesse.
Ambience & Concept
What stands out first is how AP Pizza Shop positions itself somewhere between casual and elevated. The space is relaxed—take‐out friendly—with a modern edge. But the menu and execution hint at something more refined. Indeed, the parent team behind it (notably from DC’s acclaimed All‑Purpose Pizzeria) bring an Italian‐American sensibility that elevates typical pizza fare. The Washington Post+2Bethesda Magazine+2 This is less “crawl in for a quick slice” and more “come enjoy a thoughtful pizza meal with an interesting beginning and end.”
What sets it further apart:
-
The doughs: You’ll find both New York style and Sicilian‐style pies. Bethesda Magazine+1
-
The toppings: Not just pepperoni & mushroom, but things like taleggio, whipped ricotta, black truffle honey. Toast+1
-
The sides and salads: Not afterthoughts, but dishes in their own right—salads with endive & apples, rich starters with a twist.
In short: the concept is unique in Bethesda for offering the approachability of a pizza-place but the ambition of a fine casual Italian spot.
Highlights from the Menu
Here are a few standout items that demonstrate the breadth and creativity at AP Pizza Shop:
Endive & Apple Salad
One of the more intriguing salads on the menu features crimson crisp apples, Belgian endive, Montasio cheese and candied almonds, dressed with cider vinaigrette. Toast+1
What I appreciated:
-
The endive gives a nice bitter-crisp balance, the apple adds sweetness and freshness.
-
Montasio is not your everyday salad cheese—adds depth.
-
The cider vinaigrette ties into the apple and makes it seasonal and refreshing.
If you’re seeking a salad that feels designed instead of just “lettuce + dressing”, this is it. It stands on its own as a starter.
White Pizza / “Bianco” Style
While AP Pizza Shop doesn’t label everything “white pizza,” there are pies that lean into the bianco style—for example crusts without heavy tomato sauce, using cheese, fonduta, mushrooms, or toppings like garlic breadcrumbs. On the lunch menu: “18″ Cheese Pie – Bianco di Napoli tomato sauce, mozzarella, Sicilian oregano, grana padano.” Toast+1
Additional pies include: “Funghi Pie – Parm fonduta, fontina, mozzarella, wild mushrooms, cipollini, rosemary, black truffle sauce.” Toast+1
What I found:
-
The crust is thin and crisp but still chew-worthy—indicative of a thoughtful dough development.
-
The toppings are layered, refined: wild mushrooms + black truffle sauce elevates what could be “just another white pie.”
-
The absence (or minimization) of tomato sauce in some pies allows other flavors to shine—like the cheeses and mushrooms.
Classic Meets Creative
Beyond the salad and white/bianco pizzas, AP Pizza Shop offers inventive takes on familiar styles:
-
The “Supremo” slice: tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, black olives, grana. Toast+1
-
The “Sedgewick” pie: whipped ricotta, mozzarella, taleggio, parm, chives, black truffle honey. Toast+1
-
Sammiches and other non-pizza items: a chicken parm sandwich, Italiano with salami & fresh mozzarella, etc. Toast+1
This approach means you can go very traditional, or you can experiment—and both feel valid.
Why It Feels Unique Compared to Typical Pizza Concepts
-
Thoughtful ingredient layering – Many standard pizza spots focus on toppings as an afterthought to dough + sauce. Here, there’s equal attention to dough, sauce (or lack thereof), cheese blend, finishing elements (truffle honey, roasted peppers, garlic breadcrumbs).
-
Menu breadth & balance – It’s not just pizza + salads; it’s salads that could be mains, sandwiches that hold their own, and brunch or lunch options.
-
Quality meets accessibility – While it has more refined touches, it retains the casual, approachable feeling of a pizza place (take-out window, slices, shareable pies). That duality is harder to pull off.
-
Ambience supporting the concept – The space is polished but unpretentious. Design cues, deck ovens in clear view, a vibe that says “neighborhood spot” but also “this is good.”
-
Hybrid style of pizza – Offering both NY style and Sicilian style, and pies that deviate from standard red sauce + mozzarella, creates a richer offering for pizza fans and foodies alike.
Minor Quibbles / Considerations
-
Some of the more creative pies (e.g., truffle honey, taleggio) will be higher priced than “basic” pizzas—so expect premium for premium.
-
If you’re used to ultra-bearing ultra-thin crust pizzas, the crust here may feel slightly more chewy or robust in spots because of the craft dough.
-
Because the menu is elevated in parts, the pace of service may differ from the fastest “grab-and-go” slice shops.
Overall Verdict
If you’re in Bethesda and looking for something beyond the typical pizza outing—somewhere that gives you the comfort of pizza but with sophistication—AP Pizza Shop is a very solid pick. From the crisp, inventive endive & apple salad to the elevated white pies and bold topping combinations, this place succeeds at standing out. It retains the easygoing vibe you want from a pizza shop, while offering the kind of menu that makes you feel like you’ve discovered something special.
In short: come for the pizza, stay for the creativity—and bring people who appreciate both the classic and the surprising.
